China's Carbon Trading Pilots Worsened Energy Misallocation Due to Distorted Allowance Prices, Study Finds
bioengineer.orgNew research on China's regional carbon trading pilots finds they increased energy misallocation across 30 provinces from 2000 to 2022. The study estimates that participating in a pilot raised the provincial energy misallocation index by about 2.1, with the effect growing over time. The core problem: allowance prices stayed far below real marginal abatement costs. Using provincial data and multiple econometric methods, the authors put China's average marginal abatement cost at 261 RMB per tonne of CO2, while pilot carbon price distortion ranged widely across regions. When permits are cheap, heavy industry has little reason to shift away from high-carbon fuels. The paper identifies two channels: constrained energy inputs and weaker green innovation. This is not a general argument against carbon markets. It is a warning about design. Administrative quotas, price floors and ceilings, thin trading, and fragmented registries can turn a carbon market into a source of allocative friction instead of a clean price signal. For policymakers building China's national ETS, the pilot results are a practical checklist of what to fix.
